I mean, I managed to argue in S&S and the mod was absolutely fine with my reasons for that, so I think there's some leeway within fandoms.
I saw that discussion, looking through the admin posts. They barely even questioned it, did they? So, yeah, it seems like there's a pretty broad scope.
(I also found the highly detailed discussion about whether Good Omens might qualify weirdly hilarious. There's a random alien in that one scene that might or might not actually exist! They talk about running off to Alpha Centauri! Crowley helped make a nebula once! Despite the vast weight of all that evidence, I really can't argue against the decision to leave it out. Even if I would happily read/write all the Good Omens space fic. :))
(Do you also possibly want to request or offer stuff about an alien who travels in space and time in a police box?)
I do and I will! The only question is can I narrow down those fifty possible tags at all.
I saw that discussion, looking through the admin posts. They barely even questioned it, did they?
I know, I was having to be both sides of the argument, so then I just went with it. I flit between whether or not that was really justified, but then again, I think it does fit within their rather wide definition, so I'm not going to feel bad.
I really can't argue against the decision to leave it out. Even if I would happily read/write all the Good Omens space fic.
To be fair, though, it probably wouldn't be much less justified than S&S!!
no subject
Date: 23 Feb 2020 09:46 pm (UTC)I saw that discussion, looking through the admin posts. They barely even questioned it, did they? So, yeah, it seems like there's a pretty broad scope.
(I also found the highly detailed discussion about whether Good Omens might qualify weirdly hilarious. There's a random alien in that one scene that might or might not actually exist! They talk about running off to Alpha Centauri! Crowley helped make a nebula once! Despite the vast weight of all that evidence, I really can't argue against the decision to leave it out. Even if I would happily read/write all the Good Omens space fic. :))
(Do you also possibly want to request or offer stuff about an alien who travels in space and time in a police box?)
I do and I will! The only question is can I narrow down those fifty possible tags at all.
no subject
Date: 24 Feb 2020 09:49 am (UTC)I know, I was having to be both sides of the argument, so then I just went with it. I flit between whether or not that was really justified, but then again, I think it does fit within their rather wide definition, so I'm not going to feel bad.
I really can't argue against the decision to leave it out. Even if I would happily read/write all the Good Omens space fic.
To be fair, though, it probably wouldn't be much less justified than S&S!!